Home

Obstacles ahead for the Youth Guarantee

Press Release 

A report published today by the European Court of Auditors (ECA) identifies three risks to the successful implementation of the EU Youth Guarantee initiative supported by €12.7 billion of EU funding: adequacy of total funding, the definition of a “good quality offer”, and the way the Commission monitors and reports on the results of the scheme.

The EU auditors conclude that the Commission provided timely and appropriate support to the Member States in setting up their Youth Guarantee schemes. Yet they also note that it did not carry out an impact assessment specifying expected costs and benefits, despite this being a standard procedure for all major Commission initiatives. As a result, there is no information on the potential global cost of implementing the scheme across the EU and, consequently, a risk that total funding may not be adequate. Together with the lack of a clear definition of a "good quality" job offer, this represents a major risk that the scheme might be implemented ineffectively and inconsistently across the EU.

The EU auditors recommend that:

• The Member States provide a clear and complete overview of the cost of all the planned measures to combat youth unemployment under the Youth Guarantee scheme so that the Commission can assess the overall funding needs;
• the Commission promote a set of qualitative attributes that jobs, traineeships and apprenticeships should possess to qualify for EU support. This could be based on the elements which define a good quality offer in the Commission's Guidance on Evaluation of the Youth Employment Initiative;
• the Commission put in place a comprehensive monitoring system for the Youth Guarantee scheme, covering both structural reforms and measures targeting individuals. The results of this monitoring should be reported to the European Parliament and the Council.
 
Entire press release of 24th of March, available here: http://www.eca.europa.eu/Lists/News/NEWS1503_24_SR15_03/INSR15_03_EN.pdf
Special report no 3/2015: EU Youth Guarantee: first steps taken but implementation risks ahead